Blog powered by Typepad

« Why Can't I Get Anything Done? | Main | Americana Circus Tent »

July 27, 2023

Comments

Cathy

I'm with you on the open casket situation but I think Eva is old enough to attend a memorial service. She will probably hear a lot of very positive things about her grandpa, stories she may not have known, and be left with good memories of him. Of course, there may be some tears too but I expect she can handle it.

BTW, I love that block, it is perfection!

Nancy

In my experience she is old enough to attend, but suggest she be allowed to drive how much she participates, meaning she should decide if she wants to go up to the casket or not. Interacting with others, remembering her grandpa, hearing (and maybe telling) stories are all part of the grieving, and healing, process...and a way to begin dealing with the feelings she is going to have at the loss of her grandpa in a supportive environment.

Jill Schaumloeffel

I think it is a good idea your daughter attends the celebration of life service. She needs the experience of celebrating her grandparent's life. It's not the open casket situation. She needs to learn the cycle of life and, although we are sad at a loved one's passing, we can remember and cherish the memories with them.

Susan

My son was only 10 when his beloved grandfather died. He lived next door and they were buddies! He was devastated but came to the funeral home ,mostly hung out near the back of the room. The casket was in the front. We let him decide if he wanted to view his grandfather.

So sorry for your loss.

Mary

One of my great uncles passed away when I was eight. He and his wife raised my dad. While seeing him in a coffin didn't really bother me, seeing my dad cry was very touching. But in the long run, I think it was good to see him have a soft side like everyone does. To this day, I cannot remember another time seeing him cry.

Pamela Dempsey

Sounds like a celebration of life would be a lot easier on everyone. At 11 our Sunday school class went to the viewing of another 11 year old member who had drowned. The boys in our class were on a camping trip and some went in the water unsupervised and he got tangled in whatever was growing, couldn’t get loose, drowned. He had bruises and it was traumatic to see him laying in a coffin. I didn’t want to go to the funeral and luckily my dad gave me the choice. It’s given me a fear of drowning and a respect of water’s danger. That was 53 years ago.

Nancy Alderman

From the time I was a toddler I was taken to the funeral home whenever a friend or family member died (my parents and grandparents knew a lot of people!). To my mind, it made things so much easier for me when it came to funerals for my close family and friends. I knew what to expect and how to deal with the grief. I think it’s the not knowing that causes so many problems for people when they have to deal with death for the first time as adults. Eva might have questions and concerns, but this will help her on the road to acceptance and understanding. Just my humble opinion!

Debbie R.

I definitely think Eva should go. It's an opportunity to see how much so many people cared about her grandfather, to hear lots of stories about him, and to share in the grief. It's also a concrete opportunity to realise he is really gone, and to continue the process of grieving and saying goodbye.

Bevann

I believe a celebration of life is the best way to honor someone---not a fan of open casket---Eva is a smart cookie, and as others have said, she can hear stories of her grandpa, and hold those close to her. Death is part of life, and this will be an opportunity to see and learn what happens, and start processing her grief.

kit

call it what you may, there is still the elephant (coffin) in the room. with our girls we made attendance mandatory, but participation at their own volition. don't look unless you want to (they won't look like you remember them ), you can sit with us or in the lobby (wherever you feel comfortable) know that we are sad, but lots of stories will be told that you have never heard before (bet you never knew that!?), cemeteries can be places of beauty (look around at growing things), when its all over, hug the dog!!

kit

ps kids will take their clues from you. relax.

Diane

I think attending funerals and memorial services are a great chance to honor and remember loved ones. We do a lot of talking and telling stories before, during, and after. We talk about why we cry—that we are lonely for their company. My grands all attended their great grandmother’s funerals and loved it. It’s also a wonderful family time. It’s all about the conversation surrounding the event.
On another note:I remember when Eva was born. I’ve been following you a long time and enjoy being part of your journey

wanda/exuberantcolor

I think it is important for children to learn the celebration of life angle while they are young. Then they can understand the happiness of the people sharing the stories and how much the deceased shared with all of them when alive.

Ina

how heartbreaking to lose her grandfather. the best services to me are when people share their memories of the one that is gone. her poor grandmother must be devastated. I hope the service brings some comfort to all of you. lots of hugs to all of you.

Jan

I think Eva is both old enough & wise enough to join the family to remember her grandfather. She may even feel left out if she weren't included in the day. We attended a celebration of life for longtime friends with their family in June. Their two adult kids scattered their ashes in a meadow in a national park (permit required). The great grandkids (4 & 6) were with the 9 adults & saw our tears as well as heard the laughter over a couple of days together. I believe they understood we were sad but were also enjoying the shared memories. Being so young they took to coloring & drawing when we were indoors but I think they understood that the grown-ups needed to be together for a little while to tell our stories. I agree with the others that it's a natural circle of life experience that Eva can be a part of.

Suzanne

My husband and I have taken our kids to 4 funeral/memorial services. Last month, it was to the funeral of our 44-yr-old sister-in-law. I grew up going to the funeral services of my extended family members who passed (my dad had a huge Italian family), plus my mother passed before I was grown. So, I thought it was normal to take kids to services. You know how what you grow up with is your own "normal", right? My husband had never been to one until he was an adult, so he didn't think kids went to this sort of thing. When the first one came up for us after our kids were born, I said it was important to me for our kids to go -- to experience all the things of life, which includes death. And we handled it how my parents had: LOTS of talking. Ahead of time, we explained roughly how it would all go and what to expect. And then we continually welcomed questions and answered whatever they asked. When we had to go to that devastating funeral last month, our kids were emotionally and behaviorally ready to face that hard, hard day (not that one can ever be truly "ready" -- they were at least "practiced"). Some of their cousins hadn't been to any funerals before, and it was certainly even more difficult for them on that day because the whole setting was new.

Jeanie

Growing up Catholic, I attended many open casket wakes. It was just what happened after someone died, and I really did not think anything of it. Death was part of life, as was taught as I was growing up. That being said, I did not like walking up to the open casket to say my goodbyes. It was many times the only memory I had of the person who past away. It really sticks out in a young person's mind. Knowing what to expect is helpful!

April

My son attended his Grandfather's celebration of life at 11 a year and half ago. While he was emotional, he did fine and I think it was better for him and his sister (8) to attend and have closure. I am very sorry for your loss!

Chookyblue

Never done an open casket but I would not like to do that either.......Eva's age I would let her decide what she wants to do......if she wants to go or stay home........Just having ashes will be different but I recently got caught at a small gathering for family to toss some ashes into a river..... I have never had anything to do with ashes but I found it a bit confronting to be handed the container and tip some ashes in the river also...(and not slide into the muddy rivers edge and drop the container also).....but I was not expecting to do this until the container was passed to me.......I may have felt a bit better if I had been prepared in my mind prior........
Let Eva decide but maybe give her a heads up at what might happen there......also different for an old person who has lived a long life.......so many stories can come out.....wonderful to find these things out.......

Frances

When my Mom passed away recently all her great grandchildren attended. The difference was there was no viewing, it was a few weeks after her death and the emphasis was on sharing my Moms wonderful life, viewing pictures, sharing memories. It was a positive experience for them.

Colleen

I think it's better for Eva to go and see what it's all about than imagine it and for her to feel like she's a part of it and the family. It was normal for us, as children, to go to funerals. My BIL didn't go to a funeral until he was 14 - unfortunately it was his fathers' so double the trauma. I always like it when parents bring their babies and toddlers to the grands' funerals because it is such a good distraction from all the sadness and a reminder that life carries on.

The comments to this entry are closed.