In 2023 I read 146 books. 60 in print, 63 on my Kindle, 23 on audio. I must be choosing my books better because I had a fantastic reading year, with a whopping 24 of them being rated 5 stars, and 56 of them rated 4-4.5 stars. Without a doubt, my preferred genre is historical fiction, and my favorites reflect that. I read a lot of newly published books, but this year I did delve into my backlist, reading books published in years past.
It was hard to pick my favorites, so I have two lists for you. Today I will share my 12 top books of the year. Later this week I will share 12 close runners up. I have tried to keep my synopses brief and encourage you to read more complete reviews on Goodreads or Amazon. I also have more book reviews on my Goodreads account, which you are welcome to follow.
Frozen River by Ariel Lawhon was my number one book of the year and a perfect read for winter. The story takes place in the winter of 1789 and is based on the actual diaries of Martha Ballard, a midwife in Maine. A despised local man is found frozen in the Kennebec River and 54-year-old Martha becomes involved due to her medical experience and evaluation of the cause of his death. Very atmospheric and suspenseful.
Tom Lake by Ann Patchett. What can I say? Everyone has been raving about this book since it came out last summer. I listened to the Audible version narrated by Meryl Streep, which was incredible. Set in a Michigan apple orchard during the pandemic, three grown daughters gather at home to help with the harvest. Their mother was a former actress and they beg her to tell them more of her past. This book is all about family and making choices that lead to a meaningful life. Masterful storytelling.
The Madstone by Elizabeth Crook was a dark horse in my library. If you enjoyed Paulette Jiles "News of the World" or Larry McMurtry's "Lonesome Dove", this book has a similar vibe. I adored this book, which is the story of 19-year-old Benjamin Shreve, an innocent bystander living in the Texas hill country in 1868, who gets involved in a whirlwind adventure not of his own choosing. He witnesses a stagecoach passenger being mistreated by the local sheriff, and when the stagecoach leaves with the man's fortune on board, Benjamin agrees to try to help the man catch up to the stage and his belongings. This is a tale of suspense, jeopardy, and unexpected romance that will keep you turning the pages until the very end. Benjamin's voice is droll, reasonable, and so sympathetic.
In Memoriam by Alice Winn. This book begins in 1914 at a boys' school in England and focuses on two friends Ellwood and Gaunt. The boys too young to join up to fight in WWI eagerly read the school gazette for news of their older classmates, many of whom were dying in the fighting. Soon our two main characters are themselves joining up and navigating the horrors of the war and discovering their feelings for one another. This novel is a remarkable portrayal of two young men who put their lives on hold to serve their country in the interest of a greater good and suffered terrible consequences as a result. This was a vivid and compelling read.
The Trackers by Charles Frazier. This is another winner from Charles Frazier, author of "Cold Mountain". It is 1937 and "Val" Welch has been sent to the small town of Dawes, Wyoming to paint a mural in the post office as part of one of FDRs New Deal projects. A wealthy local art patron and rancher, John Long, and his glamorous wife Eve, offer to put Val up on their property. Eve has a shady "past" and an ex-husband who may not be happy about her new marriage. When Eve suddenly disappears, John Long talks Val into playing private eye and going after her. And soon Val has some no-good desperados after him. Great secondary characters and lots of Yellowstone vibes. Great plot, terrific descriptions, and everyone is slightly unreliable. This was so good!
Weyward by Emilia Hart. This book is the story of three women in the Weyward family. Altha (1619), Violet (1942), and Kate (2019). All three share a strange gift and a strong affiliation with birds and insects. Each of the three timelines is compelling and you will turn the pages as fast as you can to find out what happens next. The book is a combination of historical fiction and magical realism, with gothic overtones. All three women have serious challenges to overcome and all seek refuge over the generations at Weyward Cottage. I loved it!
If We Were Villians by M.L. Rio. The setting of this book is a private arts college that specializes in Shakespearean drama. The book is set up in five parts, like the five acts of a Shakespeare play and there are seven main characters who are typical of the characters you would find in a Shakespearean history or tragedy. The book begins with one of the students being released from prison ten years after supposedly murdering one of his cohorts. The lead detective on the case never truly believed the young man was guilty and finagles an interview with him on his release from prison to find out what really happened. The story is a richly layered tale of obsession, passion, and friendship that pulled me in from the start.
The Square of Sevens by Laura Shepherd-Robinson is a book I am surprised more people aren't talking about. Set in Cornwall in 1730, a young girl known as "Red" accompanies her father throughout the countryside, telling fortunes with an ancient tarot-style method called the Square of Sevens. Her father dies suddenly after entrusting Red's care to a gentleman scholar they meet while traveling. He is a kind man who raises her as a lady in the town of Bath. As she matures, our main character, now known as Rachel, has a lot of questions: Who was her mother? Who were the enemies her father always warned her were looking for them? A series of circumstances causes Red to go into hiding when her guardian dies, and she must support herself by reverting to her fortune-telling to survive and discover her past. Great mystery, major plot twist at the end, very Dickensian in style and atmosphere.
The Meaning of Night and The Glass of Time are two books by Michael Cox. In the first book, "The Meaning of Night", our main character does some pretty dastardly deeds, but he has his reasons. Our main character, Edward Glyver goes from the grubby streets of Victorian London to Evenwood, a beautiful estate that he has been cheated out of inheriting. Edward is passionate in his quest for justice and revenge against his arch-rival, the dastardly evil poet Phoebus Rainford Daunt. There are plenty of betrayals, treachery, and obsession in these pages. I was totally obsessed to find out what would happen. The atmosphere of Victorian England is masterfully portrayed.
The Glass of Time continues this story of revenge. The narrative continues with a female main character, Esperanza Gorst impersonating herself as a lady's maid to the Baroness Tansor, the previous fiance to the villain Phoebus Daunt from "The Meaning of Night". Our fake maid soon learns that her mistress has many secrets, but how it all relates to her remains to be seen. I don't want to give anything away, but this book ties up all the loose ends left hanging in "The Meaning of Night". The ending is also enormously satisfying. If you enjoy Victorian drama, great prose, and wonderful characterizations, you might love these two books as much as I did.
Beyond That, the Sea by Laura Spence Ash is another book I am surprised not to be hearing more raves about. The story begins in 1940 England with working-class Londoners Millie and Reginald Thompson sending their 11-year-old daughter Bea to America to live with another family to keep her safe until the war is over. Her temporary family, the Gregorys, live in Boston and have a summer home in Maine. They also have 2 sons near about Bea's age. As she gets close to her lovely American family, it is a struggle for Bea to have her heart and home on two different continents. This is a powerful book, with deep and complicated relationships between characters you will care for. This is a totally fresh WW2 perspective, taking place in America.
I end my 2023 Favorites list with a re-read, that is completely worth your time to re-visit.
September by Rosamond Pilcher. This is a book you will immerse yourself in and be sorry to let go of when you finish it. Set in September in the Scottish countryside, it is the story of a group of people who gather to celebrate the birthday of a local young woman. As you meander through the book, getting to know the various characters and enjoying the descriptions of their everyday life, you will not immediately be aware of the tension that is building throughout the story. It is a slow-building family saga, full of secrets and issues begging for resolution. I highly recommend this highly satisfying book. If you read it back in the 80's, give it another go!